PHOTO: J. Keeler Johnson
June 27, 2017

When I have a construction or repair project, I stop to ask myself whether screws or nails will be better-suited to the task at hand. Both are commonly used for projects involving lumber—building horse stalls, working on fences, building a tool shed, you name it—and in many cases they’re interchangeable, with one being as good as the other.

But for some tasks when deciding on screws or nails, one has an advantage over the other. While there’s no way that I can list these advantages for every project you might encounter, I have gained a few insights from my own experience with screws and nails. Here are a few general pros and cons that I consider when choosing between screws or nails.

Screws

Pros: Because of their threaded design, it’s nearly impossible to pull a screw straight out of its hole—you have to physically turn the screw to remove it. This is an advantage in any scenario where you need to hold something together under pressure: Whereas a nail might slip back out of its hole, a screw is much less likely to do so.

Screws are also easily removable and reusable, making them suitable for use whenever you need to frequently repair or replace a given item. For example, I use screws on fencing projects so that if one of the posts rots or suffers some other form of damage, I can easily separate the post from the other parts of the fence.

Cons: Screws have two main disadvantages. One disadvantage is the huge variety of screw types on the market—Phillips, slot, square, star, you name it. This means that in many cases, you need a large collection of screwdrivers and drill bits to handle any screw type you might encounter.

Another disadvantage: You’ll need an electric drill for installing and removing the screws for most construction projects, at least ones that use screws of any significant size. This isn’t a big deal, and it’s nice to let the drill do the work, but it does mean that you’ll need to have batteries charged and ready whenever you need to use the drill.

Nails

Pros: Nails offer a number of subtle advantages over screws. For delicate work on small sections of wood that might be prone to splitting, nails can often do the job without damaging the wood. They’re also the perfect choice for use with cloth and similar materials; the rotating action required to install screws can cause the cloth to wrap around a screw (a definite nuisance), so nails—which are installed by pounding them straight into place—can be a better choice.

In addition, because nails require no rotation during installation, they are available in more unusual shapes than screws. For example, you can purchase nails that are shaped like staples, only much larger. This design—essentially two nails joined together by a curve of metal at one end—can be perfect for projects such as attaching wire to fence posts.

A smaller benefit: The only tool you need to install or remove nails is a claw hammer—the ultimate in portability, with no batteries or power source required. Even better, you know that a claw hammer will work just fine with the vast majority of nail types, making it a “one size fits all” type of tool.

Cons: Perhaps the biggest con with nails is that they aren’t as easy to remove as screws. In fact, removing nails can frequently cause cosmetic damage to the item you’re removing them from. At the same time, nails are more likely than screws to pop out of place when under pressure; small nails in particular can work loose fairly easily and tend to have some trouble holding things together.

What factors do you consider when choosing between screws and nails?


Next Up