Trying to cut back on the stuff is a challenge. There is more to drinking coffee than just a caffeine addiction: It’s about the flavor of the bitter tannins, the rich roasted smell, and the relaxing feeling of drinking something warm. In trying to halve my caffeine intake, I’ve been trialling some potential coffee substitutes, with varying success. Though these three roasted elixirs don’t have the energy jolt of a cup of joe, they check some of the other boxes in terms of satisfying a coffee craving.
1. Kentucky Coffeetree (Gymnocladus dioicus)
I received some seeds of this North American native tree from a friend in Canada. Hardy to USDA zone 3b, the tree’s seeds and pods were used as a coffee substitute by settlers. The handling of parts of this tree as a food should be careful and deliberate, however, as it contains a toxic alkaloid call cytisine. This compound is neutralized when the seeds and pods are properly roasted.
I planted most of my seeds, but also tried to see if the plant made good on the promise in the name. It’s certainly a coffee-like, but as others have indicated, it’s a very crude substitute.
2. Chicory Root (Cichorium intybus var. sativum)
Chicory root has long been cultivated in Europe to be roasted as a rather convincing caffeine-free coffee substitute. It has been widely used in times of war, shortage, poverty or famine to stretch existing coffee supplies. In France, it’s a normal part of regular coffee. The flavor of a brew made of roasted chicory root is smooth, slightly sweet, tannic and suitable for satisfying a craving for a slightly bitter warm beverage.
3. Dandelion Root (Taraxacum spp.)
Dandelion root coffee—made from cleaned, dried, sliced and roasted dandelion taproots—is my personal favorite coffee substitute. Long used in herbal medicine as a diuretic and tonic for the liver, dandelion root coffee is a healthy alternative to java. It has an almost caramel-like flavor, and in my humble opinion, smells heavenly when it is brewing. On the other hand, my partner, expecting coffee, spit out his cup of steeped roasted dandelion root.
It goes without saying that all of these beverages are a matter of personal taste, but finding the perfect placeholder can be well worth it when trying to cut down on caffeine.