Overcoming Hurdles in Onion Production

One researcher makes breakthroughs in decreasing onion bacterial rot and reducing soil erosion to improve onion yield.

by Dani Yokhna
Reducing planting space to 4 inches could reduce onion loss to bacterial rot by 63 percent. Photo courtesy iStockphoto/Thinkstock (HobbyFarms.com)
Courtesy iStockphoto/Thinkstock
Reducing planting space to 4 inches could reduce onion loss to bacterial rot by 63 percent.

Onions are one of New York’s most valuable vegetable crops, but growers face a host of production challenges: Bacterial rot cuts deep into profits, and the fragile muck soil that most onions are grown in is susceptible to as much as 1 foot of erosion every 10 years.

Fortunately, the toolbox of solutions to these onion problems is expanding fast, thanks to promising research projects taking place at the Cornell University Extension. There, vegetable specialist Christine Hoepting is using a series of Sustainable Agriculture Research and Education grants to investigate new onion-growing approaches, from conservation tillage to mulches to planting techniques to soil fertility.

In one study, Hoepting found that reducing plant spacing by half (to 4 inches) could reduce yield loss to bacterial rot by 63 percent beyond growers’ standards. This could boost net profit by up to $258 per 100-foot bed for fresh-market onions. Using alternatives to black plastic mulch—which absorbs sunlight and can create favorable, warm conditions for bacteria—yielded similarly positive results.

“A lot of growers became aware of how they can manipulate mulches and plant spacing, so they’re experimenting on their own now,” Hoepting says.

One of those growers is Matt Mortellaro, who raises 200 acres of onions for retail distribution on his family farm in Elba, N.Y.

“We’ve increased densities of our transplanted onions,” Mortellaro says. “It sometimes results in smaller bulb sizes, which can earn less on the market, but the increased quality more than makes up for it.”

Subscribe now

Another unexpected finding helped Hoepting leverage a $10,000 SARE grant into a $220,000 grant from the Northeastern Integrated Pest Management Center. After noticing that onions grown in a low-lying area of one test plot suffered disproportionately high damage, she speculated that nitrogen buildup was feeding soil bacteria. She’s now studying the relationship between nutrient levels and bacteria incidence.

Mortellaro, like most of New York’s larger-scale onion growers, plants most of his crop in muck soil, which is rich in organic matter but very friable because it was created from drained wetlands. Wind damage poses a serious problem under conventional tillage practices, especially during planting season.

“I’ve seen 4-foot drifts of muck. It reminds me of snow,” Hoepting says. “Onions can be decapitated or pulled right out of the ground by strong winds when they’re young.”

While many farmers plant protective windbreaks of barley between onion rows, the young onions are vulnerable to wind damage in the spring until the barley has grown tall enough to offer protection. Hoepting compared minimum-tillage systems that left the residue of fall-planted oat and wheat cover crops on the ground to a conventional system that plowed the residue under. She found the residue left from minimum tillage protected both the soil and the onions, effectively preventing erosion and improving net profit by 9 percent compared to the conventional system.

“It’s right only for certain acreage,” Mortellaro says, referring to a farm’s most wind-exposed fields, but he plans to take advantage of cover-crop residue on 30 acres of his land. “It’s working to my economic benefit enough that I’m going to continue doing it,” he says.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *